Kew District scorecard – Legislative Assembly (lower house)

Boroondara Reconciliation Network Treaty and reconciliation scorecard – Kew District

← All 2026 State Election scorecards and how we rate candidates and parties

How the candidates for Kew District in the Legislative Assembly (lower house) rate on Treaty and reconciliation, based on their published policies.

Who supports Treaty?

Good on Treaty and self-determination

  • Jackie Carter (Greens)
  • Sophie Torney (Independent)
  • Samantha Lincolne (Victorian Socialists)
  • David Sun (Labor)
  • Juliet Hales (Animal Justice Party)

Poor on Treaty and self-determination

  • Jess Wilson (Liberal)
  • Finlay Davis (Independent)
  • David Laird (One Nation)
  • Ann Seeley (Family First)

None – no relevant published commitment

  • Man Liang (Independent)

Full ratings in all eight categories, and the evidence for each, are below.

How to vote

On your Kew District ballot paper, you must number every box.

  1. Number every candidate who supports Treaty above every candidate rated Poor on Treaty – this matters most.
  2. Give your 1 to whichever candidate rated Good you prefer – if they are eliminated, your vote passes on in full.

Printed scorecard

Boroondara Reconciliation Network scorecard for Kew District, showing each candidate’s rating (Good, Partial, Poor or None) in eight categories. The same ratings are in the table below.
The Kew District scorecard. Tap or click to see it full size.

All ratings

CandidateTreatyYoorrookJusticeChildrenRacismHealth housing economyEducation cultureCountry heritage
Jackie CarterGreensGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGood
Sophie TorneyIndependentGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodGood
Samantha LincolneVictorian SocialistsGoodGoodGoodGoodGoodPartialGoodPartial
David SunLaborGoodPartialPoorGoodGoodGoodGoodGood
Juliet HalesAnimal Justice PartyGoodPartialGoodNonePartialNoneNonePartial
Jess WilsonLiberalPoorPoorPoorPartialNonePartialNoneNone
Finlay DavisIndependentPoorNonePoorNonePoorNoneNoneNone
David LairdOne NationPoorPoorPoorNoneNoneNoneNoneNone
Ann SeeleyFamily FirstPoorPoorNoneNoneNoneNonePoorNone
Man LiangIndependentNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNoneNone

Rating key

GoodPartialPoorNone

Good means explicit support and substantial relevant commitments address most of the category. Partial means some relevant commitments are published, but coverage is incomplete, broad, indirect, lacking implementation detail or not sufficiently First Peoples-specific. Poor means a published position conflicts with the category’s central objective. None records that no sufficiently specific published commitment was found by the evidence cut-off; it does not necessarily mean opposition.

Policy evidence by candidate

Open a candidate to see the policy quotation, the reason for each rating, and links to the sources.

Jackie CarterGreens

Treaty and self-determination

Good
Policy quotation
“We will always vote to defend Treaty.”

Why this rating: The Greens say they will “always vote to defend Treaty” and “stand against any attempt to repeal or water-down Treaty”. They voted to pass the Statewide Treaty Bill in 2025.

Category sources: Greens First Nations & Treaty policy | Greens vote to pass the Treaty Bill (14 October 2025)

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Good
Policy quotation
“The Greens will implement all, starting with an initial investment of $50 million.”

Why this rating: They commit to implement all Yoorrook recommendations, beginning with an initial $50 million investment. Their anti-racism policy also says racism must be addressed through “justice and truth telling”.

Category sources: Greens First Nations & Treaty policy | Greens multiculturalism and anti-racism policy

Justice reform

Good
Policy quotation
“The Greens will raise the age of criminal responsibility to 14, as recommended by experts.”

Why this rating: The policy promises to raise the age of criminal responsibility to 14 and to “repeal Labor’s 2025 bail changes and life sentences for kids”. It also supports care for First Nations prisoners by Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations.

Category sources: Greens First Nations & Treaty policy

Protecting children

Good
Policy quotation
“The Greens want to ensure child protection for First Nations kids is centred on culture, self-determination and human rights.”

Why this rating: The Greens’ child protection policy notes that First Nations children “continue to be overrepresented in care” and commits to child protection centred on culture and self-determination, with fair support for kinship and other carers. Their First Nations policy supports “ongoing development of child protection and culturally relevant family support projects”. Their justice policy adds that “kids belong in schools and in communities, not in prison”.

Category sources: Greens social services and child protection policy | Victorian Greens First Nations Peoples Policy | Greens First Nations & Treaty policy

Opposing racism

Good
Policy quotation
“Racism is a wicked problem that causes direct harm to First Nations people and communities of colour.”

Why this rating: The Greens’ anti-racism policy says racism “must be tackled at its roots and be grounded in justice and truth telling”, identifies the over-policing of people perceived to be Aboriginal, and proposes anti-racism programs in the school curriculum. Their justice policy commits to “fix our discriminatory prison and criminal justice system”, and their First Nations policy commits to “eradicating personal and institutional racism.”

Category sources: Greens multiculturalism and anti-racism policy | Greens First Nations & Treaty policy | Victorian Greens First Nations Peoples Policy

Health housing and economy

Good
Policy quotation
Housing policy: “The housing needs of First Nations people should be met as a matter of urgency, and should be self-determined, culturally appropriate, and located wherever they choose to live.” Health platform: “… supporting and expanding community health and Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations …”

Why this rating: The Greens commit to expanding Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisations, “culturally safe support for First Nations people” in mental health care, and Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation care for First Nations prisoners. Their housing policy requires First Nations housing to be self-determined and culturally appropriate, with access to secure long-term housing wherever people live. Their First Nations policy supports “establishing targets in employment of First Nations peoples in all government sector organisations”, employment pathways for young people, and funded programs for First Nations business and economic development.

Category sources: Greens health platform | Victorian Greens Housing and Homelessness Policy | Victorian Greens First Nations Peoples Policy | Greens First Nations & Treaty policy

Education language and culture

Good
Policy quotation
“Expand the inclusion of the history, culture and contemporary experiences of First Nations peoples in the school curriculum, and in the education and professional development of all teachers.”

Why this rating: The Greens’ education policy also commits to more First Nations teachers and support workers and more “language, reading, and cultural materials” for First Nations students, says language education is crucial “to prevent loss of language amongst migrant and First Nations communities”, and supports First Nations communities to help design and deliver education. Their First Nations policy protects the right to practise and revitalise culture and language, and their early childhood platform supports First Nations frameworks and ways of knowing in early childhood education.

Category sources: Victorian Greens Education Policy | Victorian Greens First Nations Peoples Policy | Greens early childhood education platform

Country and heritage

Good
Policy quotation
“First Nations people are the experts when it comes to caring for Country.”

Why this rating: The Greens support “more respect for Traditional Owner water rights, so First Nations people are better able to care for Country”, funding for “First Nations-led work protecting and restoring Country”, and forest management “with Traditional Owners’ rights and management front and centre”. Their First Nations policy supports strengthening the Aboriginal Heritage Act so that heritage decisions are made by Traditional Owners and “items of First Nations cultural heritage are returned to and managed by Traditional Owners”, and Traditional Owner rights to own and manage lands, resources and waters.

Category sources: Greens First Nations & Treaty policy | Greens agriculture and water policy | Greens nature policy | Victorian Greens First Nations Peoples Policy

Source: Victorian Greens 2026 platform and Victorian Greens party policies (individual pages linked under each category)

Party policy applies to this candidate.

Sophie TorneyIndependent

Treaty and self-determination

Good
Policy quotation
“I will stand up for Treaty in Parliament and oppose any attempt to repeal the Statewide Treaty.”

Why this rating: Torney says she will “stand up for Treaty in Parliament” and oppose repeal, while protecting and funding the institutions needed to make Treaty effective.

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Good
Policy quotation
“I will advocate for full implementation of Yoorrook’s recommendations, led by First Peoples, with adequate funding, clear targets and timelines, and public reporting.”

Why this rating: Her policy makes “truth-telling, fairness and Country” a stated priority and calls for public accountability, visible progress and commitments with timelines.

Justice reform

Good
Reconciliation and Treaty policy quotation
“I support raising the age of criminal responsibility and funding culturally safe prevention, early intervention and alternatives to imprisonment.”
Community Safety policy quotations
“I support the expansion of YCPEIP (Youth Crime Prevention + Early Intervention Program) and other youth intervention programs … as measures to reduce youth crime and recidivism.”

“Victoria’s new bail settings should be reviewed by experts, not internal cabinet processes, to ensure we strike the right balance.”

Why this rating: Torney’s Reconciliation and Treaty policy supports raising the age of criminal responsibility, although it does not specify an age. It also supports culturally safe prevention and early intervention, alternatives to imprisonment, action to prevent deaths in custody, an alternative justice pathway for minor offences—especially for First Peoples—and sustained funding for Aboriginal-controlled justice services. Her Community Safety policy reinforces the prevention approach by proposing expanded youth intervention programs and an expert review of bail laws, with the report and recommendations made public. That policy also calls for more police and says she is broadly supportive of stronger penalties for bail breaches and offences committed while on bail. However, it criticises “tough on crime” rhetoric, cites the Law Institute of Victoria on the disproportionate effect of tighter bail laws on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and other vulnerable groups, and proposes an expert review with the report and recommendations tabled publicly, rather than a fixed punitive outcome. Read together, the policies provide substantial support for most of the category while leaving the precise age and final bail settings to be specified. Her bail position is a proposal for independent expert review, not a commitment to tougher settings, and it sits within a policy centred on prevention, alternatives to custody and Aboriginal-controlled justice services, so it is not treated as conflicting with the category’s central objective.

Category sources: Sophie Torney policy page | Sophie Torney Reconciliation and Treaty policy (PDF) | Sophie Torney Community Safety policy

Protecting children

Good
Policy quotation
“I will advocate for fewer children being removed from their families …” and “… sustained funding for Aboriginal-controlled justice and family services.”

Why this rating: It supports Aboriginal-led prevention and family services and responds to Yoorrook findings about the over-representation of Aboriginal children in care.

Opposing racism

Good
Policy quotation
“I will publicly challenge racism, racial scapegoating and racist misinformation, including in Parliament.”

Why this rating: Treaty is presented as enabling “true representation and systemic equality”. The policy also commits to challenging racism and strengthening accountability.

Health housing and economy

Good
Policy quotation
“I will advocate for adequately funded, Aboriginal-controlled health, mental-health and housing services, culturally safe care, and First Peoples-led action on homelessness.”

Why this rating: The policy promises to deliver on Closing the Gap and build First Peoples’ economic participation through Aboriginal-led services and measurable outcomes.

Education language and culture

Good
Policy quotation
“I support First Peoples-led teaching of accurate history and colonisation, truth-telling in schools and public institutions, language revival, and protection of cultural rights and programs.”

Why this rating: “Support education, language and culture” is a stated priority, including truthful history, Aboriginal languages and culturally safe learning.

Country and heritage

Good
Policy quotation
“I support Traditional Owner authority in managing Country, stronger cultural-heritage protection, water rights recognised in law and cultural flows, and joint or Traditional Owner management of public land.”

Why this rating: Country is included in the policy’s truth-telling priority, with support for Traditional Owner authority, cultural heritage and caring for Country.

Source: Sophie Torney policy page | Sophie Torney Reconciliation and Treaty policy (PDF)

Samantha LincolneVictorian Socialists

Treaty and self-determination

Good
Policy quotation
“Extend the powers of state-wide and local Treaties and support and implement the demand for increased First Nations control over First Nations affairs.”

Why this rating: Victorian Socialists will “extend the powers of state-wide and local Treaties” and increase First Nations control over First Nations affairs.

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Good
Policy quotation
“Implement all recommendations of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody, the Bringing them Home Report, and the Yoorook [sic] For Justice and Transformation Reports.”

Why this rating: The party promises to implement all recommendations of Yoorrook, Bringing Them Home and the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody.

Justice reform

Good
Policy quotation
“Implement all recommendations of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody …” and “Increase access to First Nations legal, health and social support services.”

Why this rating: Victorian Socialists commit to implement all recommendations of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody and the Yoorrook for Justice report, and to increase access to First Nations legal services. The policy states that “the criminal justice system in particular is racist and brutalises First Nations people”.

Protecting children

Good
Policy quotation
“End the contemporary stolen generation by reducing the number of First Nations children in out-of-home care.”

Why this rating: The policy promises to “end the contemporary stolen generation” by reducing the number of First Nations children in out-of-home care.

Opposing racism

Good
Policy quotation
“First Nations people continue to endure profound oppression, discrimination and racism.”

Why this rating: It identifies continuing “oppression, discrimination and racism” and supports stronger First Nations control, material redress and institutional change.

Health housing and economy

Partial
Policy quotation
“Increase targeted spending to rapidly equalise the health, education and socio-economic outcomes of First Nations and non-Indigenous people.”

Why Partial: The policy supports targeted spending and First Nations services, but it does not commit to Aboriginal-controlled housing delivery, secure multi-year service funding, employment or procurement targets, or measurable Closing the Gap outcomes.

Education language and culture

Good
Policy quotation
“Protect cultural rights and provide greater support to retain and restore culture and languages lost due to colonisation and genocide.”

Why this rating: It supports restoring culture and languages, funding First Nations language teaching and teaching invasion, continuing injustice and First Nations resistance.

Country and heritage

Partial
Policy quotation
“Sovereignty over land, water and sky was never ceded.”

Why Partial: The policy affirms sovereignty, land rights and reparations, but it does not commit to Traditional Owner water rights or cultural flows, cultural-heritage law reform, Traditional Owner park management, or cultural-fire programs.

Source: Victorian Socialists policy

Party policy applies to this candidate.

David SunLabor

Treaty and self-determination

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 8): “Sustainably fund and resource Gellung Warl to continue their work in relation to Treatymaking”

Why this rating: Labor policy commits to “sustainably fund and resource Gellung Warl”, give effect to Treaty and participate in Local Traditional Owner Treaty negotiations.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Partial
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 7): “Acknowledge, recognise and respect our state’s Aboriginal legacy and history as outlined in the Yoorrook Justice Commission’s Truth Be Told report”

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Why Partial: Labor policy recognises Yoorrook findings and supports continuing truth-telling, but it does not commit to implementing all recommendations through a complete, time-bound and publicly reported program. The rating acknowledges that the Labor Government established Yoorrook and legislated the Statewide Treaty institutions that continue truth-telling and monitor implementation of Yoorrook recommendations (Nyerna Yoorrook Telkuna and Nginma Ngainga Wara). Partial reflects the absence of a forward commitment to implement all recommendations on a timetable, not a lack of past action.

Justice reform

Poor
Policy quotation
Labor Government (December 2025): “That means courts will treat these children like adults, so jail is more likely, and sentences can be longer.” Labor Government (August 2024): “The Government will not, however, raise the age of criminal responsibility to 14.” Victorian Labor election commitment (8 November 2026): “Courts need another option to deal with low and mid-level youth offending.”

Why this rating: Labor policy contains positive commitments on Yoorrook justice findings and culturally safe services. However, the Labor Government expressly abandoned its age-14 commitment, introduced tougher bail laws that increase remand, removed last-resort protections, and enacted adult-court sentencing for some children aged 14 and over. These measures conflict with essential Yoorrook justice reforms and result in a Poor rating. These measures are not a superseded record. Labor’s 2026–2030 Platform lists “Introduced Adult Time for Violent Crime” among its achievements (p. 82) and commits to “Ensure community safety is paramount in decision-making around bail and sentencing” (p. 86), without any commitment to reverse them. The Platform also contains positive justice commitments, including supporting “self-determination projects as we work to reduce incarceration and meet Closing the Gap outcomes in the justice system” (p. 88) and meeting “international benchmarks in youth justice and incarceration” (p. 84). These do not outweigh enacted laws that the current Platform itself endorses. On 8 November 2026 Labor went further, promising a “Mandatory Therapeutic Order” under which children who commit low and mid-level offences such as theft, vandalism and minor assaults would be detained 24 hours a day for up to 12 months in secure youth justice facilities, including Malmsbury, with re-sentencing to youth detention if they breach the order. The Victorian Aboriginal Legal Service called it “mandatory sentencing dressed up as political leadership”. Locking up more children for low-level offending conflicts directly with Yoorrook’s call to keep children out of detention, confirming the Poor rating.

Category sources: Decision not to raise the age to 14 | Adult Time for Violent Crime law | Tough bail laws | Earlier commitment to age 14 | Labor “tough love” youth detention plan (8 November 2026) | AAP: VALS response (8 November 2026)

Protecting children

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 7): “… embed self-determination across all government departments, agencies and decision-making systems, with a particular focus on those relating to health and wellbeing, justice and youth justice, child protection and education” and (p. 64): “Ensure culturally safe out-of-home care for First Nations and multicultural children”

Why this rating: The Platform commits to embed self-determination in child protection, culturally safe out-of-home care for First Nations children, sustainable funding for Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations to provide specialist services, and Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisation-led early childhood education services.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Opposing racism

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 90): “Tackle racism and discrimination in building a truly inclusive and equitable society” and (p. 55): “Work in partnership with Aboriginal organisations to address systemic racism in healthcare”

Why this rating: The Platform promises to “tackle racism and discrimination”, address systemic racism in healthcare in partnership with Aboriginal organisations, eliminate racism in the public service workforce and break down discrimination barriers in Aboriginal housing, alongside embedding self-determination across government.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Health housing and economy

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 7): “Support and sustainably fund Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations to provide specialist services …” and (p. 101): “Grow and strengthen the Aboriginal housing sector, ensuring Aboriginal-controlled organisations lead delivery”

Why this rating: The Platform supports sustainable funding for Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisations, culturally safe care and self-determination in Aboriginal health, Aboriginal-controlled housing delivery and home ownership pathways, and Aboriginal employment plans and First Nations employment outcomes.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Education language and culture

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 47): “… support schools to have confidence to embed First Nations histories and culture in the curriculum, while continuing to deliver the Marrung Aboriginal Education Plan”

Why this rating: The Platform supports First Nations histories and culture in the curriculum, the Marrung Aboriginal Education Plan, Aboriginal Community Controlled Organisation-led early childhood education, and First Peoples creative industries and cultural heritage programs.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Country and heritage

Good
Policy quotation
Labor Platform (p. 119): “… acknowledges Traditional Owners as inherent rights holders rather than ‘stakeholders’ in the management of public lands and natural resources”

Why this rating: Traditional Owners are recognised as “inherent rights holders”. The Platform supports Traditional Owner sole management of selected national parks, the Victorian Traditional Owner Cultural Fire Strategy and Aboriginal-led protection of cultural heritage.

Category sources: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF, copy hosted by BRN)

Source: Victorian Labor policy website

Party policy applies to this candidate.

Note on Labor sources: Quotations marked “Labor Platform” are from the Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (Australian Labor Party, Victorian Branch), with page numbers given. It is a public document but had not been published on Labor’s website by the evidence cut-off, so the Boroondara Reconciliation Network hosts an unaltered copy: Victorian Labor Platform 2026–2030 (PDF). The platform currently available on Labor’s website is the earlier 2022–2026 edition, which is a different document.

Juliet HalesAnimal Justice Party

Treaty and self-determination

Good
Policy quotation
“The AJP supports self-determination and empowering First Nations communities.”

Why this rating: The AJP’s First Nations position sheet supports self-determination and commits its representatives to consult directly with local Indigenous leaders, including on treaty. Its Victorian MP, Georgie Purcell, voted for the Statewide Treaty Bill at its final vote in the Legislative Council on 30 October 2025.

Category sources: AJP First Nations position sheet | Hansard: Statewide Treaty Bill third reading vote, 30 October 2025 | AJP First Nations page

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Partial
Policy quotation
“The AJP supports establishing one or more Makarrata Commissions to facilitate truth-telling and agreement-making.”

Why this rating: The AJP supports truth-telling through Makarrata Commissions, but does not commit to implementing the Yoorrook Justice Commission’s recommendations.

Category sources: AJP First Nations position sheet

Justice reform

Good
Policy quotation
“Australia must adopt the United Nations suggested age of 14 years for criminal responsibility.”

Why this rating: The AJP supports raising the age of criminal responsibility to 14 and favours diversion, “especially First Nations designed and led programs”. Its position sheet highlights continuing Aboriginal deaths in custody and says major reform is urgently required.

Category sources: AJP age of criminal responsibility position | AJP First Nations position sheet

Protecting children

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led child protection was identified.

Opposing racism

Partial
Policy quotation
“The AJP will always support equality (one of four core values) and oppose oppression.”

Why this rating: The AJP commits in general terms to equality and opposing oppression, and its position sheet names systemic discrimination against First Nations people, but it has no specific anti-racism measures.

Category sources: AJP First Nations page | AJP First Nations position sheet

Health housing and economy

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: The AJP says it is not its place to decide unilaterally on social or economic issues of special concern to First Nations people, and commits to consult. No specific commitment was identified.

Category sources: AJP First Nations position sheet

Education language and culture

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples education, language or culture was identified.

Country and heritage

Partial
Policy quotation
“Create partnerships with First Nations Peoples practising cultural burning”

Why this rating: The AJP’s fire management policy supports partnerships with First Nations people practising cultural burning, and its climate policy supports “governance and solutions that enable First Nations People to adopt these leadership roles” in protecting nature. It has no commitment on cultural heritage law.

Category sources: AJP fire management policy | AJP climate change policy

Jess WilsonLiberal

Treaty and self-determination

Poor
Policy quotation
Jess Wilson, Liberal leader (3AW, 19 November 2025): “I oppose the treaty, and that’s our position as a party … We have said that we will repeal that … in the first 100 days. That is our position, and that position is not changing.”

Why this rating: Jess Wilson has committed a Liberal government to repeal the Statewide Treaty in its first 100 days. The Liberals and Nationals have also said they would replace the elected First Peoples’ Assembly with an unelected advisory body. The party’s earlier position was: “We do not support a treaty, and we do not support a Victorian version of a Voice to Parliament.”

Category sources: Liberal position on Treaty (July 2025) | Opposition vows to scrap Treaty within 100 days (National Indigenous Times, 14 October 2025) | Jess Wilson on 3AW: “we will repeal that … in the first 100 days” (News24, 19 November 2025) | New Liberal leader reaffirms plan to abolish Treaty (National Indigenous Times, 20 November 2025)

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Poor
Policy quotation
“We do not support a treaty, and we do not support a Victorian version of a Voice to Parliament.”

Why this rating: The conflict is institutional and practical, not just rhetorical. The Statewide Treaty gives effect to specific Yoorrook recommendations by establishing Nyerna Yoorrook Telkuna to continue First Peoples-led truth-telling and Nginma Ngainga Wara to independently monitor government policies, programs, services and expenditure affecting First Peoples. It also provides a pathway for Yoorrook’s Official Public Record to support truth-telling in schools. The Liberal commitment to repeal Treaty and reject a “Victorian Voice” would remove or defund the legal framework and First Peoples institutions through which those recommendations are being implemented. The Liberal Party’s own statement describes the Treaty as “divisive”, which also rejects the representative and truth-telling structures that Yoorrook recommended. This is why the rating is Poor, rather than simply reflecting silence or no reported policy.

Category sources: Liberal position on Treaty | Statewide Treaty — Parts 9 and 10 | Victoria’s Treaty information pack

Justice reform

Poor
Policy quotation
“Under a Liberal and Nationals Government serious offenders who break bail will be sent to jail.”

Why this rating: The Liberal and Nationals Safer Communities Plan, announced by Jess Wilson and Shadow Attorney-General James Newbury in April 2026, promises a one-strike rule automatically denying bail to people who reoffend on bail for serious offences, tougher breach of bail offences, removal of the youth exemption from breach of bail laws, more offences under “Adult Crime, Adult Time” laws and 3,000 more police. These are detention-oriented responses rather than the justice reforms assessed by the scorecard. Tougher bail is the core of the policy; it mentions crime prevention and rehabilitation without detail, and no published commitment was found on the age of criminal responsibility, alternatives to imprisonment, Aboriginal-controlled justice services or deaths in custody to balance it. Candidates who mention bail penalties but whose published policies centre on prevention, alternatives to custody and Aboriginal-controlled services are assessed on that wider package.

Category sources: Joint statement: Tougher bail and sentencing laws to keep Victorians safe (Jess Wilson and James Newbury, 15 April 2026)

Protecting children

Partial
Policy quotation
“First Nations Victoria will work in genuine partnership with aboriginal community-controlled organisations, traditional owners, elders and local communities to co-design and deliver services that reflect their priorities.”

Category sources: Coalition First Nations Victoria policy (joint Liberal–Nationals policy, published by the Nationals)

Why Partial: The shared Coalition First Nations Victoria policy expressly includes child and family wellbeing, identifies out-of-home care as a Closing the Gap concern, and promises partnership with Aboriginal community-controlled organisations to co-design culturally safe services. This is relevant First Peoples-specific evidence, but it does not commit to reducing removals, family preservation and reunification, transferring child-protection authority, or secure funding for Aboriginal-controlled child and family services.

Opposing racism

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples racism or discrimination was identified for the printed scorecard.

Health housing and economy

Partial
Policy quotation
“… the Liberals and Nationals believe in working constructively to address disadvantage and inequality, but that means delivering better outcomes on the ground …”

Why Partial: The policy acknowledges disadvantage, but it does not commit to secure funding for Aboriginal-controlled health services, Aboriginal housing delivery, or First Peoples employment, procurement and business-development measures.

Education language and culture

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples education, language or culture was identified for the printed scorecard.

Country and heritage

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Traditional Owner authority, cultural heritage or caring for Country was identified for the printed scorecard.

Source: Liberal policy

Party policy applies to this candidate.

Finlay DavisIndependent

Treaty and self-determination

Poor
Policy quotation
“a dossier on each indigenous person”

Why this rating: Finlay Davis’s policy document supports constitutional recognition but proposes interviewing every Indigenous person aged 10 and over and compiling “a dossier on each indigenous person”, followed by a steering committee. A government-directed examination of individuals by race conflicts with self-determination. He does not support Treaty.

Category sources: Finlay Davis national policy document | Finlay Davis policy summary

Yoorrook and truth-telling

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on implementing Yoorrook or truth-telling was identified.

Justice reform

Poor
Policy quotation
“Bail should be harder to obtain.”

Why this rating: His Victorian policy proposes to limit bail applications by imposing “strict liability” custody for certain offences. Tougher bail laws conflict with Yoorrook’s recommendations to reform bail, which drive First Peoples’ over-incarceration.

Category sources: Finlay Davis national policy document | Finlay Davis Victorian election policy

Protecting children

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led child protection was identified.

Opposing racism

Poor
Policy quotation
“a dossier on each indigenous person”

Why this rating: Singling out every Indigenous person for individual examination and a government dossier treats people differently because of their race, which conflicts with the aim of opposing racism.

Category sources: Finlay Davis national policy document

Health housing and economy

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples health, housing or economic outcomes was identified.

Education language and culture

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples education, language or culture was identified.

Country and heritage

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on caring for Country or protecting cultural heritage was identified.

David LairdOne Nation

Treaty and self-determination

Poor
Policy quotation
“Scrap the Statewide Treaty entirely. Gellung Warl will be abolished and its legislated funding ended.”

Why this rating: One Nation promises to “scrap the Statewide Treaty entirely”, abolish Gellung Warl and end its legislated funding.

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Poor
Policy quotation
“Gellung Warl will be abolished and its legislated funding ended.”

Why this rating: Its policy rejects the institutions established to continue truth-telling and implement Yoorrook recommendations, stating that Gellung Warl “will be abolished”.

Justice reform

Poor
Policy quotation
“We will return the age of criminal responsibility to 10 years old …”

Why this rating: One Nation’s justice policy directly conflicts with the scorecard objective of reducing incarceration and youth criminalisation. It would return the age of criminal responsibility to 10, sentence some children as adults, create further presumptions against bail, expand remand capacity, and escalate repeat sentences towards imprisonment. The policy contains no First Peoples-specific justice measures.

Category sources: One Nation Victoria justice policy

Protecting children

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led child protection was identified for the printed scorecard.

Opposing racism

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment meeting the scorecard’s anti-racism criterion was identified.

Health housing and economy

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led health, housing or economic opportunity was identified.

Education language and culture

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment supporting First Peoples education, languages or culture was identified.

Country and heritage

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Traditional Owner authority, cultural heritage or caring for Country was identified.

Source: One Nation policy

Party policy applies to this candidate.

Ann SeeleyFamily First

Treaty and self-determination

Poor
Policy quotation
“If elected, Family First will introduce legislation to repeal the treaty bill introduced by Victorian Labor.”

Why this rating: Family First promises to “introduce legislation to repeal the treaty bill” and rejects the Statewide Treaty framework.

Yoorrook and truth-telling

Poor
Policy quotation
“Our youngest students will be taught a distorted, one-sided view of Australian history.”

Why this rating: It opposes Yoorrook-informed truth-telling in schools, describing the historical account as “distorted” and “one-sided”.

Justice reform

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples justice reform was identified for the printed scorecard.

Protecting children

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led child protection was identified for the printed scorecard.

Opposing racism

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment meeting the scorecard’s anti-racism criterion was identified.

Health housing and economy

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led health, housing or economic opportunity was identified.

Education language and culture

Poor
Policy quotation
“No parent should accept a curriculum that paints Australia as nothing but a crime scene.”

Why this rating: Family First describes teaching based on Yoorrook’s Truth be Told report as “ideological indoctrination” and a “distorted, one-sided view of Australian history”, directly conflicting with the education and truth-telling criterion. The release also says children should be taught Aboriginal history and culture in a way that is “balanced and truthful”.

Country and heritage

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Traditional Owner authority, cultural heritage or caring for Country was identified.

Source: Family First policy

Party policy applies to this candidate.

Man LiangIndependent

Treaty and self-determination

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Treaty or self-determination was identified.

Yoorrook and truth-telling

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on implementing Yoorrook or truth-telling was identified.

Justice reform

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples justice reform was identified.

Protecting children

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on Aboriginal-led child protection was identified.

Opposing racism

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on opposing racism against First Peoples was identified.

Health housing and economy

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples health, housing or economic outcomes was identified.

Education language and culture

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on First Peoples education, language or culture was identified.

Country and heritage

None

Policy quotation: No specific relevant quotation was identified.

Why this rating: No specific relevant published commitment on caring for Country or protecting cultural heritage was identified.