Treaty FAQs

Victoria signed Australia’s first Treaty with First Peoples in November 2025. These are short, sourced answers to the questions people most often ask us. Each answer starts with the short version, followed by more detail and a source.

About the Treaty

  1. What is in the Treaty?
  2. Why have a Treaty in Victoria?
  3. What does the Productivity Commission say?
  4. What happens to the Treaty if the government changes?

Money

  1. How much will Treaty cost?
  2. Will Treaty change taxes?
  3. Don’t First Peoples in Victoria already get a lot of government money?
  4. Do First Peoples get more government spending per person than other Australians?

Rights and everyday life

  1. Will Treaty affect newcomers to Victoria?
  2. Will Treaty affect property rights?
  3. Can the Treaty override Parliament?
  4. Will Treaty give First Peoples “special privileges”?
  5. Will Treaty affect shooting, fishing or bush recreation?
  6. Will Treaty slow down development?
  7. Does Treaty mean land will be “handed back”?

Benefits and relations

  1. How will Treaty make life better for First Peoples?
  2. How can Treaty benefit people who aren’t First Peoples?
  3. Will Treaty increase division?
  4. How can Treaty improve relations between First Peoples and other Victorians?
  5. Didn’t existing laws already give First Peoples enough rights?
  6. What does “self-determination” mean in practice?

Repeal, cost and the evidence

  1. What would the Coalition put in place instead?
  2. How much would repealing Treaty save?
  3. Will Treaty pay for itself?
  4. Is there evidence that self-determination improves lives?
  5. Does Treaty create a “parallel government” or undermine the rule of law?
  6. Why not review Treaty before repealing it?
  7. How are Aboriginal children and families faring, and does Treaty matter for them?
  8. Why did the Coalition drop its support for Treaty in January 2024?

Last updated November 2026.

About the Treaty

1. What is in the Treaty?

Short answer: The Treaty sets up Gellung Warl, a permanent, elected First Peoples’ body. Gellung Warl advises government, holds it to account and leads truth-telling. It cannot veto laws, and Parliament keeps the final say.

The Statewide Treaty was signed and became law (the Statewide Treaty Act 2025) on 13 November 2025. Gellung Warl (“tip of the spear” in Gunaikurnai) began operating on 1 May 2026. It has three parts:

  • The First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria: elected First Peoples representatives.
  • Nginma Ngainga Wara: an accountability body that monitors how government is performing for First Peoples, including on Closing the Gap and the Yoorrook Justice Commission’s recommendations.
  • Nyerna Yoorrook Telkuna: carries on truth-telling and healing in local communities.

Gellung Warl advises the government and Parliament. It addresses Parliament once a year and Cabinet at least twice a year, and new Bills must include a Statement of Treaty Compatibility. It can make a small number of rules and guidelines, for example on cultural safety and on trading First Peoples’ existing water entitlements. These guidelines are non-binding and cannot conflict with State or Commonwealth law. The Treaty also includes:

  • the Yoorrook Official Public Record as a resource for schools
  • a say in naming waterways and parks on Crown land
  • a First Peoples Infrastructure Fund for community facilities
  • Aboriginal events and awards

Gellung Warl is overseen by the Auditor-General, IBAC and the Ombudsman, like other independent public bodies. Separate local treaties with Traditional Owner groups may be negotiated in future.

Source: Statewide Treaty factsheet, Victorian Government, November 2025

2. Why have a Treaty in Victoria?

Short answer: To formally recognise First Peoples’ rights and connection to Country, and to give them a lasting voice in decisions that affect them.

Past policies made decisions for First Peoples, often with poor results. Before the Treaty, no permanent, legally recognised body gave First Peoples a structured role in government decision-making. The Treaty followed the Yoorrook Justice Commission, Australia’s first formal truth-telling inquiry, which documented the harms of colonisation and recommended reforms. On 9 December 2025 the Premier delivered a formal State Apology to First Peoples in Parliament, a key Yoorrook recommendation.

Sources: Treaty factsheet; State Apology, Premier of Victoria

3. What does the Productivity Commission say?

Short answer: Its 2024 review found governments had not delivered on Closing the Gap because they had not shared power with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. It pointed to Victoria’s Treaty process as an example of the kind of change needed.

The Productivity Commission released its review of the National Agreement on Closing the Gap in February 2024. It found governments “have largely not fulfilled their commitments”. It recommended sharing power, rethinking how mainstream government works, and stronger accountability. It said Treaty, truth-telling and Voice mechanisms such as the First Peoples’ Assembly of Victoria “can also support self-determination”. It discussed Victoria’s Treaty process as an example of rebalancing power, while noting that outcomes were yet to be seen.

The review was written before the Treaty was agreed. It does not claim Treaty alone will close the gap.

Source: Closing the Gap review, Productivity Commission, 2024

4. What happens to the Treaty if the government changes?

Short answer: The Liberal–National Coalition has said it will repeal the Treaty Act if it wins government. Repealing it would need a new law passed by both houses of Parliament.

The Coalition withdrew its support for the Treaty process in January 2024 and voted against the Bill in 2025. It has proposed replacing Gellung Warl with a new advisory body and a government department. Polling commissioned by a First Nations-led group in August 2026 found most voters in 78 of Victoria’s 88 electorates did not see scrapping the Treaty as a priority for a new government.

Sources: Statewide Treaty Act 2025, Wikipedia; YouGov polling via NIT, August 2026

Money

5. How much will Treaty cost?

Short answer: About $70 million a year once Gellung Warl is fully running. Claims that it will cost billions a year are false.

The Treaty Act sets Gellung Warl’s funding:

Year Funding
2025–26 $3 million (start-up)
2026–27 $23.8 million (establishment)
2027–28 $71 million
2028–29 $72.1 million, then rising 2.5% a year

There is also $36.8 million in capital funding over 2026–29. The Victorian Government says it has spent $326.7 million on the Treaty process in state budgets since 2020–21. The Herald Sun put total spending since 2016 at $382 million.

AAP FactCheck rated the claim that Treaty will cost $2.34 billion a year as false: the figure “does not appear anywhere in the bill or budget papers”.

Source: AAP FactCheck, 15 October 2025

6. Will Treaty change taxes?

Short answer: No. The Treaty Act does not change tax laws, create new taxes or provide individual financial “reparations”.

Treaty costs are part of normal government spending, like any other program. Tax levels remain a decision for Parliament in each budget.

Source: Treaty factsheet

7. Don’t First Peoples in Victoria already get a lot of government money?

Short answer: There is targeted funding for health, education, housing and community services, aimed at closing large gaps in outcomes. Treaty is separate: it pays no money to individuals.

First Peoples make up 1.0% of Victoria’s population (65,646 people at the 2021 Census). Nationally, life expectancy for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is 8.8 years shorter for men and 8.1 years shorter for women. Targeted programs exist because mainstream services alone have not closed these gaps. Treaty is about giving First Peoples a say in how such programs are designed, not about adding new payments.

Sources: ABS 2021 Census counts; ABS life expectancy 2020–22

8. Do First Peoples get more government spending per person than other Australians?

Short answer: For health, yes: about $1.36 for every $1, reflecting greater health needs. Most of that money is people using ordinary services such as hospitals, not special programs.

In 2022–23, health spending averaged $12,146 per Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander person, compared with $8,901 per non-Indigenous Australian. About 7% of total Indigenous health spending went to First Nations-specific programs; most was hospital and other mainstream care. For some services, spending is actually lower: Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme spending was $677 per person, compared with $758. These figures are national and cover health only.

There is no simple comparison with other disadvantaged groups, because each has different needs and services. For example, NDIS support for a person with disability is often far higher per person.

Source: Health Performance Framework, measure 3.21 (AIHW)

Rights and everyday life

9. Will Treaty affect newcomers to Victoria?

Short answer: No. Treaty does not touch immigration, visas or residency, which are federal matters, and it takes away no one’s rights.

Treaty is about the relationship between the Victorian Government and First Peoples. Many multicultural organisations support it. In October 2025, the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre and 47 other organisations, including the Centre for Multicultural Youth and the Settlement Council of Australia, signed a joint statement backing Treaty. A QDOS Research survey of 2,000 Victorians, cited in that statement, found 69% support among people from post-colonial nations such as India.

Sources: ASRC joint statement, 13 October 2025; Treaty factsheet

10. Will Treaty affect property rights?

Short answer: No. The Treaty Act does not take away anyone’s home, land or property rights.

The Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities already protects Victorians from being deprived of property except in accordance with law. Future local treaties could include arrangements such as co-management of public land, but only through negotiation and new agreements.

Native title is a separate federal process. In October 2025 the Wurundjeri Woi-wurrung people lodged a native title claim covering more than 10,000 square kilometres, including central Melbourne. AAP FactCheck found claims that this could take people’s homes false: native title does not apply to privately owned freehold land.

Sources: Treaty factsheet; AAP FactCheck, 3 December 2025

11. Can the Treaty override Parliament?

Short answer: No. Gellung Warl has no power to veto policy or legislation, and Parliament keeps the final say on all laws.

The Treaty Act does not change the Constitution or create a “third chamber” of Parliament. Gellung Warl can advise, report to Parliament and request information about new laws. New Bills must include a Statement of Treaty Compatibility, but Parliament still decides.

Source: Treaty factsheet

12. Will Treaty give First Peoples “special privileges”?

Short answer: No. Treaty gives no tax breaks, individual payments, land ownership or legal rights that override anyone else’s.

What Treaty does provide is a formal voice in decisions that affect First Peoples, plus truth-telling, cultural recognition and community infrastructure. Critics say focusing on one group is “special treatment”. Supporters point out that targeted measures to address disadvantage are common, for example women’s health programs or disability access, and are allowed under anti-discrimination law.

Source: Treaty factsheet

13. Will Treaty affect shooting, fishing or bush recreation?

Short answer: No. The Treaty Act does not change hunting, fishing, camping or access rules for public land.

Existing Traditional Owner agreements already show how this works. The Taungurung agreement recognises Taungurung people’s rights to hunt, fish, camp and gather on public land, and states that “recreational activities like hunting and fishing will not be affected”. The Dja Dja Wurrung agreement says Traditional Owner rights “do not affect the access of existing users, such as recreational fishers and hunters”. Some parks are jointly managed with Traditional Owners, and recreation continues there. Access rules can still change for environmental or safety reasons, through the usual public processes.

Sources: Taungurung agreement; Dja Dja Wurrung agreement

14. Will Treaty slow down development?

Short answer: The Treaty Act does not change planning or building laws. Aboriginal cultural heritage rules for some developments already existed before Treaty.

Under the Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006, a Cultural Heritage Management Plan is required when a “high impact activity” is planned in an area of cultural heritage sensitivity. Delays in that system are a question of how heritage law is resourced and administered, not something Treaty created. Future agreements could add consultation on culturally significant land.

Source: Cultural Heritage Management Plans, First Peoples–State Relations

15. Does Treaty mean land will be “handed back”?

Short answer: No. Treaty involves no automatic transfer of land, and private property is not affected.

Where land arrangements exist, they are negotiated agreements about public (Crown) land. For example, under the Dja Dja Wurrung agreement, six parks and reserves (about 47,500 hectares, including Greater Bendigo National Park) are jointly managed by a Traditional Owner board. Under the Taungurung agreement, nine parks and reserves were granted as Aboriginal title and are jointly managed. They remain public parks, and recreational fishing and hunting continue.

Sources: Dja Dja Wurrung agreement; Taungurung agreement

Benefits and relations

16. How will Treaty make life better for First Peoples?

Short answer: By giving First Peoples a permanent, elected voice and an accountability body, so that decisions about their lives are shaped by the people affected.

Evidence to the Yoorrook Justice Commission showed that services designed and run by Aboriginal people get better results. Women’s Health Victoria put it this way: “health services by and for Aboriginal people have continually out-performed other health services.” The RACGP said Treaty and truth-telling are “crucial to overcoming Australia’s health inequalities”. Treaty also supports cultural recognition through place names, events and awards, and continued truth-telling. It is not a quick fix, but a lasting structure for change.

Sources: Women’s Health Victoria statement, September 2025; RACGP, October 2025

17. How can Treaty benefit people who aren’t First Peoples?

Short answer: A fairer, healthier community benefits everyone, and all Victorians gain from understanding the history and cultures of this place.

Better health, education and employment outcomes reduce long-term costs to everyone. Truth-telling in schools helps all Victorians, including newer arrivals, understand our shared history. Recognising the world’s oldest continuing cultures through place names, events and the arts enriches public life for everyone.

18. Will Treaty increase division?

Short answer: Treaty doesn’t divide people in law: it takes away no one’s rights. Public opinion is mixed: two of the three most recent polls found more support than opposition.

Poll Date Support Oppose
YouGov for Common Threads August 2026 40% 32%
Statewide survey of over 1,000 Victorians March 2026 53% 24%
Fox & Hedgehog for the Institute of Public Affairs October 2025 37% 42%

In the IPA poll, opposition rose to 61% after respondents were given the IPA’s own description of the Treaty’s implications. Critics, including the IPA, argue that separate structures divide Victorians by race. Supporters, including the First Peoples’ Assembly, say Treaty brings people together by recognising a shared history, as the State Apology did in December 2025.

19. How can Treaty improve relations between First Peoples and other Victorians?

Short answer: Through truth-telling, shared recognition and ongoing conversation between First Peoples and government.

The Yoorrook Justice Commission’s record will be used in schools, and the State Apology on 9 December 2025 formally acknowledged past harms. Gellung Warl gives First Peoples a lasting channel to government, rather than one-off consultations. Shared events, place names and cultural celebrations give people more chances to learn together.

Sources: Treaty factsheet; State Apology

20. Didn’t existing laws already give First Peoples enough rights?

Short answer: Existing laws ban discrimination and recognise native title, but they didn’t give First Peoples a structured, ongoing role in decisions, and large gaps in outcomes remain.

Anti-discrimination laws protect equal rights, and native title can recognise rights over some Crown land. But neither created a permanent body to advise government or hold it to account. Treaty builds on existing laws rather than replacing them. The Productivity Commission found that governments’ failure to share decision-making was a key reason Closing the Gap targets were not being met.

Source: Closing the Gap review, Productivity Commission

21. What does “self-determination” mean in practice?

Short answer: First Peoples communities having a real say, and in some areas the decision, on matters that affect their lives, culture and Country.

In practice, it includes:

  • Gellung Warl advising government and monitoring its performance.
  • The Assembly making its own rules and guidelines in defined areas, for example cultural safety and trading First Peoples’ water entitlements.
  • Traditional Owners jointly managing parks, as with the Dja Dja Wurrung and Taungurung agreements.
  • Aboriginal community-controlled organisations delivering health and other services.

All of this operates within Victorian law and under Parliament.

Sources: Treaty factsheet; Dja Dja Wurrung agreement

Repeal, cost and the evidence

22. What would the Coalition put in place instead?

Short answer: A government department called First Nations Victoria, advised by an appointed (not elected) Aboriginal advisory body. The Coalition has promised to introduce legislation to repeal the Treaty within its first 100 days.

Under Treaty, First Peoples elect the Assembly and Gellung Warl is a permanent body set up by law, independent of ministers. Under the Coalition’s plan, the advisory body would be appointed and would advise the minister. The state election is on 28 November 2026.

Sources: NIT, 20 November 2025; SBS NITV, 6 November 2026

23. How much would repealing Treaty save?

Short answer: The Coalition cites a Parliamentary Budget Office costing of $948.3 million over ten years. That figure is gross: it doesn’t subtract the cost of the department that would replace Treaty.

The $948.3 million covers more than Gellung Warl itself, which is funded at about $70 million a year once fully running. We have not found a published cost for First Nations Victoria, or for any funding that would be redirected to Aboriginal services. The real saving is therefore smaller than the headline. Money already spent on the Treaty process is gone whichever option is chosen.

Sources: Liberal Party release via Mirage News, 1 May 2026; AAP FactCheck on Treaty costs

24. Will Treaty pay for itself?

Short answer: Probably not in budget savings alone within ten years. The case for Treaty rests on better lives, recognition and fairness, not on a quick financial return.

Our own rough analysis compared Treaty with the Coalition’s alternative. To recover its extra cost purely through savings in out-of-home care or prisons, Treaty would need to perform much better than a department would. That is possible but unproven, because Gellung Warl only began operating in May 2026. The human benefits of fewer children removed from their families and fewer people in prison are larger than the budget savings, but no one has yet put a value on them.

25. Is there evidence that self-determination improves lives?

Short answer: Yes, especially where First Peoples have real authority over services, land or resources. The evidence that advisory bodies alone improve outcomes is thinner.

  • Canada: research for the C.D. Howe Institute found modern treaties boosted incomes in First Nations communities and led to more resource development.
  • British Columbia: a First Nations Health Council negotiated the transfer of federal health programs to a First Nations Health Authority in 2013. In 2023 Canada renewed its funding at $8.2 billion (Canadian) over ten years.
  • Australia: the Productivity Commission found governments’ failure to share power was a key reason Closing the Gap targets were not being met. It also found few programs had been rigorously evaluated.

Gellung Warl’s main route to better outcomes is indirect: pressing government to hand services and funding to Aboriginal community-controlled organisations.

Sources: C.D. Howe Institute (Aragón); CBC, 2023; Productivity Commission

26. Does Treaty create a “parallel government” or undermine the rule of law?

Short answer: No. Gellung Warl cannot make laws or veto them, and Parliament can change or repeal the Treaty Act like any other law.

Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has said Treaty “creates a parallel, or a separate system of governments”. Legal experts told AAP FactCheck that “all legislative and executive authority remains with the Victorian parliament and government”. Section 75 of the Act says nothing in it “limits the power of a House of the Parliament to conduct its business”. Gellung Warl is overseen by the Auditor-General, IBAC and the Ombudsman. The Coalition’s own pledge to repeal the Act in 100 days shows Parliament remains in charge.

Some people see a permanent body defined by Aboriginal descent as at odds with equal citizenship. Others worry about the political influence of an elected body. Supporters reply that Treaty recognises First Peoples’ distinct status as the first peoples of this land, not race. These are differences of values.

Sources: NIT, 20 November 2025; AAP FactCheck, 13 November 2025

27. Why not review Treaty before repealing it?

Short answer: Gellung Warl only began operating on 1 May 2026, so no one can yet judge its results.

A 100-day timetable leaves no room for an independent review, public submissions or proper consultation with Aboriginal communities. Important questions would be answered only after repeal: what First Nations Victoria would cost, how its advisory body would be chosen, and what would happen to community-controlled services. The Coalition’s view is that the election itself is the test, since its policy was announced more than a year ago.

28. How are Aboriginal children and families faring, and does Treaty matter for them?

Short answer: Victoria removes Aboriginal children at a far higher rate than other children, and Aboriginal imprisonment is rising. Treaty is meant to shift decisions and funding to Aboriginal organisations, which the evidence suggests do better.

Measure Figure Source
Children in out-of-home care, per 1,000 (2024–25) 95.8 Aboriginal vs 4.4 non-Aboriginal VAGO, June 2026
Aboriginal share of all children in care (30 June 2025) 31.2% (2,922 children) VAGO, June 2026
Aboriginal children on protection orders under an Aboriginal organisation’s authority (2024–25) 499 (14.9%) Aboriginal Affairs Report 2025
Share of child protection funding going to Aboriginal community-controlled organisations (2022–23) 7.4% SNAICC Victorian review, 2025
First Nations people in Victorian prisons (end of May 2026) 1,094, up 209 in a year NIT, 29 June 2026

Aboriginal children make up almost a third of children in care. Yet Aboriginal organisations receive only a small share of child protection funding and have authority over about one in seven Aboriginal children on protection orders. The share of funding going to community-controlled organisations is the measure to watch, whichever party governs.

29. Why did the Coalition drop its support for Treaty in January 2024?

Short answer: It cited concerns about secrecy, cultural heritage laws and the risk of division, and said it wanted to focus on practical outcomes. Its support had only been formal since mid-2022.

The Coalition was not always a supporter. In 2018 it opposed the first Treaty law, the Advancing the Treaty Process with Aboriginal Victorians Act, arguing a treaty should be done nationally. In June 2022 it changed its position, committing to “advancing the treaty process in Victoria”, and backed the law creating the Treaty Authority.

On 21 January 2024, Nationals leader and Aboriginal affairs spokesman Peter Walsh announced on Sky News that the Coalition was withdrawing its support. The reasons it gave were:

  • Secrecy: Walsh said the Coalition was “very concerned about the secrecy” of negotiations.
  • Cultural heritage and Traditional Owner laws: Walsh said Treaty should not proceed until problems with the Aboriginal Heritage Act and the Traditional Owner Settlement Act were resolved. He said cultural heritage surveys add to construction costs.
  • Division: Opposition Leader John Pesutto spoke of “the possible divisive nature of treaty”, including suggestions of separate justice and child protection systems.
  • Outcomes: Pesutto said he was “championing a focus on real life outcomes” in employment, housing, education and incarceration.

The decision came three months after the Voice referendum, and soon after Queensland’s Liberal National Party dropped its support for a treaty. The Victorian Coalition did not give the referendum as its reason. The First Peoples’ Assembly said it had not been told in advance. Its co-chair Rueben Berg called the decision “disappointing, but not surprising”.

Sources: AAP, January 2024; NIT, 22 January 2024; SBS NITV, 23 January 2024; SBS News, June 2018

Sources

All links were checked in November 2026.